February Round-Up

It felt like I was back on track with reading this month, but it's almost on par with January! With the exception of the manuscripts I read for Split/Lip Press, phew! I read 33 this month and there are more coming in right before the deadline! I can't wait to see what's chosen.

Too Old for This by Samantha Downing. I forgot how this book got on my radar but I’m so glad it did. I absolutely love Lottie and the chapter cliffhangers were just intriguing enough without giving me an anxiety attack like some thrillers try to do. That also means the resolution to this book felt right and realistic, instead of being a letdown like a lot of current thrillers end up. Definitely reading more by Downing ASAP.

Green by Melissa Fite Johnson. My poetry book for the month. I’m biased because I’ve gotten to know Melissa as a friend, but this collection is so emotional and powerful. The little moments give way to deeper thoughts and feelings that have me thinking about my daily life and interactions in more poetic ways, wishing I could put them into words as beautifully as Melissa has done in this collection.

Kill for Me, Kill for You by Steve Cavanagh. I liked this one - the twists were ones I didn’t really see coming, mostly because the writing was so strong that I was propelled along, page after page, without feeling the need to stop and dissect what was happening to try and figure out what comes next. I like how it all wrapped up and will read more by this author.

Mystery in the Mansion by Lauren Magaziner. I read this aloud with my son because we love mysteries and choose your own adventures. I previously read this on my own.

My Lovely Wife by Samantha Downing. This book was interesting but I’m glad it wasn’t the first of Downing’s I read, because it didn’t make me want to read more. (Too Old for This was the first I read and I HIGHLY recommend it.) This one felt stale to me because the trope of the educated man who is level-headed and doesn’t use contractions secretly being a psychopath feels overdone. I feel like I’ve heard this voice too many times before. I also hated all of the characters so I didn’t care if it all went up in flames. Characters don’t have to be likeable but if I don’t care at all, I’m not going to enjoy the book.

A Twisted Love Story by Samantha Downing. I like Downing’s writing style a lot but this story just wasn’t it for me. It’s the third book I’ve read of hers, and the second where I really didn’t like any of the characters. The storyline wasn’t that compelling either - I wanted more, to have it really ramped up, but it almost read like a season of a CW show to me.

Delicious Strangeness by Stephanie Barbé Hammer. My writing book for the month. Just reading this really helped me understand what I love about magical realism and how I can pull it into my own writing more. The prompts kickstarted my imagination and I’m going to re-read this immediately, slowly, giving myself time for each prompt to see what I can create.

For Your Own Good by Samantha Downing. This one gave me twisted Tom Perrotta vibes, which I liked! I thought it was interesting without being overly suspenseful. It’s the fourth Downing book I’ve read, and the second one I really liked. I still recommend Too Old For This first, but this one is also worth a read.

Carver Country: The World of Raymond Carver by Raymond Carver. Beautiful coffee-table type book of Carver’s writings and letters with photographs of him, his desk/office, and the land where he lived and set many stories. The selections of his stories and poems went well with the photographs, but the letters and introduction by Tess Gallagher were my favorite parts because they were so eye-opening.

Out There by Kate Folk. I loved Sky Daddy but I am IN LOVE with these short stories. And Folk’s brain. These stories were fascinating and weird and many had wonderful twists at the end. “The Turkey Rumble” was especially a favorite that I didn’t think I’d like much at all when I started it, but the ending made it all worth it. I love that she’s not afraid to have narrators die in the end.

Stolen from the Studio by Lauren Magaziner. The second book in the Case Closed choose your own adventure mystery series. A re-read for me, but I’m reading it aloud with my kid this time. We take turns both reading aloud and making the choices.

He Started It by Samantha Downing. Downing’s books are so hit or miss for me. I’ve read 5 now and loved one, liked one, and trudged through the others. I love road trip books and this one had a lot of potential for suspense but it felt so lacking to me. Reading it was like wading through mud. I only finished thinking that the ending had to be worth it but… womp womp. Just a big no for me.

January Round-Up

As 2025 came to an end, I gave myself a few reading goals. My overarching goal is to read books from my shelves, because I've bought a lot of books that sound great, then get distracted when my library holds come in, or someone recommends a book to me, yada yada yada. But beyond that, I want to read one writing book each month, and one poetry collection each month. While I feel like I didn't read much this month (dammit, doomscrolling), I did accomplish those two goals by the skin of my teeth.

Though I didn't read as much this month as I usually do according to trackability, I did read 9 short story/flash fiction collection manuscripts for Split/Lip Press, with more to read over the next two months. So I can't claim those since they're not published...yet, but I've read some great ones.

The Dragonet Prophecy (Wings of Fire, #1) by Tui T. Sutherland. My son wanted me to read this book because he loves this series. It was more violent than I thought it would be considering how much he likes it, but overall it was a good book and an interesting premise. I don’t think I’m going to blaze through the entire series soon, but if I don’t know what to read, it’s definitely something I’d be willing to pick up and see what happens.

Short Cuts by Raymond Carver. Part of my short story project for the month. I originally read this in 2008 or 2009 and probably watched the movie around then, too. I’ve re-read some of the short stories since, but this is the first time I re-read the entire collection. I read it right after watching the movie again so I liked seeing how the director interpreted some of the stories.

Murder with Lemon Tea Cakes by Karen Rose Smith. I read this for the Cozy Mystery Book Club. I love culinary cozies and I’m a tea fan, so I liked that aspect of the storyline. The mystery was fairly intriguing as well. However, the writing style seemed really basic. I was always aware I was reading a book because everything was told and explained instead of shown through action and dialogue, so that was disappointing. Daisy was a weak character, too. She had no personality and deferred to men so much. She was a widow and mentioned her late husband a bit, which is understandable, but she kept saying she “didn’t know why” she had feelings for handsome, kind Jonas, but also went on dates and seemed trying to force something with Cade, which had been her prom date but was really dismissive and somewhat controlling of her. I found it off-putting that she kept acting like she wanted to be with him even after admitting how he treated her annoyed her. Get a backbone! I wouldn’t have finished this if it wasn’t for book club. Read the full review here.

The Life of Chuck by Stephen King. Read this on the recommendation from a writer friend who watched the movie. I like reading the books first to see what I imagine, so I got this from the library immediately. I love the story structure and how innovative it is to have the world exist because one person’s mind created it. This was a short story made up of beautiful moments and I read it in just an hour or so because I couldn’t put it down. Even with the sad ending (at the beginning), it was so wonderful that I just wanted to crawl inside of the story. I can’t wait to compare it to the movie.

Very Nice by Marcy Dermansky. Wasn’t sure what to expect with this one but it was a nice, quick read as a snow storm blew into my area. I read it in one night. I liked the different points of view and how all the characters came together. The ending was a little lackluster to me, considering Chekhov’s gun and how much potential there was there, but I liked the author’s writing and would read more from them.

My Sister, the Serial Killer by Oyinkan Braithwaite. I’d heard about this since it came out and was intrigued based on the title alone. My favorite aspect of this book was definitely the cultural insights. I think the title definitely sets a different idea in your mind and the story didn’t live up to THAT, for me, but it was still enjoyable and I loved how some chapters were short, reading almost like flash fiction pieces, and sometimes the chapter titles came directly into play with the content so you had to keep it in mind as you read. The ending was kind of meh though, like leading into more of the same instead of a resolution.

The Secret of the Old Clock by Carolyn Keene. I love mysteries but have never read a Nancy Drew book, so I wanted to start with the original. It was an interesting book, definitely providing a glance back at the time. I don’t think it’s interesting enough to read the whole series, but I know there are some “modern” spins on it, I think with a younger Nancy as the main character, so I’ll probably give those a try too, just to see. I didn’t necessarily dislike the book, but I don’t think it stands the test of time and can hold its own in the current literary field.

 

Writing Creativity and Soul by Sue Monk Kidd. My writing book for the month. I’ve read several of Kidd’s novels, years ago, but didn’t know she’d written a writing book. It was exactly what I wanted (and needed) to start the year fresh. I love her approach to writing and how she shared finding inspiration, nurturing an idea until it becomes a story, and more. I highlighted so much in this book - really helpful quotes to revisit when I feel stuck in my own writing.

The State That Springfield Is In by Tom C. Hunley. My poetry book for the month. Maybe a cheat because it’s a re-read and I know I’d love to read it again, but honestly, I should have been re-reading it every year since my first time (in 2020) because it’s just that good. My previous review: These poems were told in the voices of Simpsons characters - beloved and obscure. It was pretty eye-opening to think of these characters as real people, and they randomly pop into my head and make me remember them as more than just fictional sitcom characters. I can’t recommend this enough to Simpsons fans, poetry fans, or people who love fictional characters as if they were real.

Convenience Store Woman vs. Sky Daddy

Convenience Store Woman by Sayaka Murata, translated by Ginny Tapley Takemori

vs

Sky Daddy by Kate Folk

I read both of these books in December 2025 and saw some similarities. As far as I can remember, both were recommended in the back of The Collected Regrets of Clover by 

Mikki Brammer (but my memory is terrible so don't hold me to that). I was on library hold lists for both and got access to Convenience Store Woman first.

I've previously read translations, including the Before the Coffee Gets Cold series, and I appreciate how hard it can be to translate work and keep the author's original intentions and the beauty of their language. I also know that there's still a lot lost, and cultural context can certainly shape your interpretation of a book.

It took me a bit to get through the book, but here are my thoughts:

Convenience Store Woman by Sayaka Murata, translated by Ginny Tapley Takemori. This book was interesting until incel Shiraha came into play. His rants were too realistic and repetitive, so I had to skim a lot of his sections. The resolution definitely improved my thoughts of the book, but I was much more intrigued by the essay included at the end that spawned the book idea. I like the concept of the romantic relationship with the store more than the overall novel itself.

When I got access to Sky Daddy, I read it all basically straight through. Here are my thoughts:

Sky Daddy by Kate Folk. I wanted to read this book because the title made me laugh and I was curious about how the concept would play out, but damn did it become my favorite read in December 2025! I read it in about a day and keep thinking about it. I wish it had gone on longer just because I want to immerse myself in Linda’s world more, but I have to say the ending is PERFECT and I would be so angry if it ended any other way.

Overall, there were a lot of similarities with the main characters, in my opinion. I'm not sure if they were meant to be autistic or just... "different" because honestly, the more adult women I meet, the more I feel that we're all drastically different in wonderful ways, and without a diagnosis and being told if someone is autistic, it's hard for me to tell. But these characters were certainly not "typical" female main characters, and I love them both for that.

That said, they were both a bit naive, moreso the narrator in Convenience Store Woman. She seemed oblivious to how she was being treated by the incel and put up with it for appearances, and I wish she was stronger than that. The Sky Daddy narrator seemed to be using the man as much as he was using her and kind of turned that situation on its head by the end, which was more satisfying, whether it was "wrong" of her or not.

I think the "relationship" in Sky Daddy was more interesting and engaging. I think that's what the author of Convenience Store Woman was trying to do, but it didn't come off that way because the incel derailed things, whereas in Sky Daddy, nothing came between the narrator and her planes. I'm not sure if that relationship aspect was something lost in translation or if it just wasn't really present in the story. It was definitely clear in the essay at the end, so I think that was the intention, but maybe the author didn't want to follow it through for the novel, or maybe it was an editorial decision.

If I had to recommend just one, it would definitely be Sky Daddy. I keep thinking about the ending and am ready to read it again, honestly, because the writing style was so engaging and I'm willing to just read anything and everything about this character's daily life.

Have you read one or both of these? What were your thoughts?

December Round-Up

I felt like I was in a reading slump for most of the month, but it doesn't really look like it... It just wasn't as enjoyable of a reading month as usual. I finished a few series, though, and got some inspiration from Lily King like I always do when I re-visit Writers and Lovers.

The Mystery of Locked Rooms by Lindsay Currie. This was a fun, adventurous read, but I felt like the problems the main character and her friends had felt really tacked on just to give the story depth. There was also a lot of detail in some scenes, then the book would totally skip over some major action just to get them to the next room/plot point. Younger readers who like Mr. Limoncello, Book Scavenger, etc, would probably like this.

The Cure for What Ales You by Ellie Alexander. This was a major book in terms of the background story of Sloan’s history, but I found it a bit tough to follow. I couldn’t piece together everything she was discovering about people from her past and have it make sense, so it fell flat for me.

The Tattered Cover by Ellery Adams. This one took a bit for me to get into, and I’m not 100% on board with Nora and McCabe moving forward for some reason, but I’m so invested in the series that I’m sure it’ll work out and I’ll be fine with it. This one felt a bit scrambled to me, but that might have just been my mindset as I was reading it. I felt like it wasn’t as rooted in the town or bookstore this time for some reason.

Heart the Lover by Lily King. I LOVE Writers & Lovers so when I heard this was connected, I knew I had to read it. King’s writing is fantastic and though the ending seemed a little overwrought, that final line SENT ME. I immediately got out my copy of Writers & Lovers to re-read (it’s been 4 years!).

Writers & Lovers by Lily King. This is my third read of the book and it never fails to put me in such a comforted state of mind, as strange as that may sound. Something about the writers surrounded by writers fuels my creativity. This time I was reading it to better understand how Heart the Lover fit in but it still conveyed the same mood and got me writing.

Convenience Store Woman by Sayaka Murata. This book was interesting until incel Shiraha came into play. His rants were too realistic and repetitive, so I had to skim a lot of his sections. The resolution definitely improved my thoughts of the book, but I was much more intrigued by the essay included at the end that spawned the book idea. I like the concept of the romantic relationship with the store more than the overall novel itself.

Rest Ye Murdered Gentlemen by Vicki Delany. I’m not a huge Christmas fan but liked the idea of this Christmas town and thought I’d give the book a try to get in the spirit. However, it fell flat for me. The main character felt like a paper doll in her actions and reactions. And she had two men pursuing her but didn’t seem to care, and it wasn’t really played up much, despite basically being the cliffhanger at the end of the book. It wasn’t compelling enough for me to want to continue the series.

Death in Castle Dark by Veronica Bond. I heard there was a new third book in this series so I wanted to re-read the first. This is SO cozy to me - I love the mystery dinner theater concept, and set in a castle makes it that much better. This is one I'll definitely re-read again.

Castle Deadly, Castle Deep by Veronica Bond. This one didn’t pull me in as much as the first. I thought Nora’s relationship drama seemed kind of middle school and immature, and that dragged on for most of the story. Some of the twists were good though, so the ending redeemed the book overall.

Sky Daddy by Kate Folk. I wanted to read this book because the title made me laugh and I was curious about how the concept would play out, but damn did it become my favorite read in December 2025! I read it in about a day and keep thinking about it. I wish it had gone on longer just because I want to immerse myself in Linda’s world more, but I have to say the ending is PERFECT and I would be so angry if it ended any other way.

Death at a Castle Christmas by Veronica Bond. This was a bit too sweet for me. It felt like it was more of a clean romance than a cozy mystery. The ending seemed especially over the top, with everyone getting engaged for Christmas? After dating six months? I also felt like the storyline of the men trying to find treasure in the castle was a bit too similar to the last book, which is disappointing. I’d read another installment if it went back to “seeing” the murder mysteries performed in the castle - I think there could be 3 or 4 unique storylines around that concept and I wouldn’t think it was too played out.

Mrs. Wilson's Affair by Allyson Reedy. I wanted to love this one. It’s no secret I love Gatsby and retellings, and I was interested to see things from Myrtle’s point of view. But this was a real struggle to get through. Most of it was Myrtle’s interior thoughts, and I get that happens when you’re isolated and having an affair, but they were SO repetitive. Then there were weird little asides that made me all too aware I was reading a book, like “Since Myrtle wasn’t present enough to recount the details, here they are:” and “The sins, for the uninitiated or the merely forgetful, are:” Some of it was also really heavy-handed, like after showing Myrtle thinking of two things, it literally says “One symbol actually there; the other imagined.” You’ve got to trust the reader to pick up on these things. Way too much telling rather than showing. I think affairs have so much potential for emotions and guilt and hopefulness and I didn’t feel any of that here.

Always Happy Hour by Mary Miller. I’ve been wanting to read more short stories and this collection interested me with Miller’s Mississippi proximity. I like her writing a lot but the stories were pretty depressing, which I understand can be the point and “the vibe” and that’s fine! But so many were little glimpses of bad relationships with bad boyfriends and it became hard to tell them apart after a few. I like the narrators and would like to see them in different situations instead of always centering men.

Save the Cat! Writes a Novel by Jessica Brody. I’ve been reading the YA version of this book but read the OG (well, not the REAL original, but still) for a Sisters in Crime book club-type discussion. It’s really helpful to learn how the same story beats can work in so many different ways to help you ensure your idea is complete enough for a novel.

November Round-Up

Absolutely Normal Chaos by Sharon Creech. After re-reading Walk Two Moons, I wanted to read this one because I never realized it came before Sal’s story! I loved getting more insight into Mary Lou and recognizing some of the things mentioned in the second book - drastically different writing style and storyline compared to Walk Two Moons though!

A Good Hard Look by Ann Napolitano. This book instantly transported me back in time to Milledgeville. I loved getting a peek inside Flannery’s life, and I love how everyone's lives twisted together. This book is the epitome of literary fiction to me - getting to know everyone at a leisurely pace and letting it build until it all unwinds. It gave me Tom Perrotta vibes in a way. Read more here.

The Collected Regrets of Clover by Mikki Brammer. This might be one of my new favorite books. I was totally immersed in Clover’s world and really identified with her in so many ways, probably more than any other character I’ve “met.” I loved the different ideas around death and how Clover kept notes for the people she worked with. I thought the romance was a bit rushed and too romance-novel-y, but overall this was so good that I’ll admit maybe I’m just jealous of what she found in the end. Read more here.

A Daughter's Guide to Mothers and Murder by Dianne Freeman. I love this series and read the first seven installments earlier this year. I was looking forward to this one, even though I skipped the novella that came before it (but read it after). Thankfully, it all stands on its own, and it was nice to revisit these characters. However, I didn’t find the mystery too compelling - I think the characters involved with the murder were too much on the periphery, so the stakes felt too low. Still a quick, cozy read, though, and I’ll continue on with the series.

George and Frances Roll the Dice by Dianne Freeman. This was a good novella to satisfy the “honeymoon” need for George and Frances without devoting a whole book to it. I understand it was a novella but everything felt a little flat and rushed to me; however, that could be because I just read book 8 and was kind of rewinding to read this, so I already knew some bits that came next, and the rest was like fitting puzzle pieces into things I had seen in book 8.

Death on Tap by Ellie Alexander. I didn’t love this one as much as the first in The Body in the Bookstore series but I love the cute little town and the mysteries that seem like they’ll span more of the series, so I’m definitely going to read a few more. It felt like the main mystery in this book was resolved way too cleanly, though, right at the end, after being dragged out and looking at so many other suspects. More of the story focused on the cheating husband (which got a bit repetitive) than the mystery. But I like the cliffhanger of Sloan’s past, so that’s the main reason I’ll read on.

The Twits by Roald Dahl. I read this as a kid and vaguely remembered the Twits themselves, but not the whole story. I wanted to re-read it before watching the movie. The Twits are disgusting and the description of Mr. Twit’s beard almost made me stop reading, but I love the Muggle-Wumps and how they outsmarted the Twits in the end.

Kinsey and Me by Sue Grafton. I’ve read this one before but didn’t remember much, so it was time to revisit. I LOVE the Kinsey Millhone short stories - quippy and satisfying in terms of the mystery. Some of the personal stories were really hard to read, and after a few I had to take a break because they really got me down. It strikes me how literary Grafton’s writing really was though - those stories seem like things we could have read in some college English/writing courses.

The Sherlock Society by James Ponti. This was such a fun read - I love that the grandfather was part of the crew. I think all the characters are unique and fun and would recommend this to younger readers - plus *I* want to see what happens later in the series!

The Unwedding by Ally Condie. Was this a thriller? It didn’t play up the suspense, though the potential was there. Instead, it felt like I was ambling around the rainy resort with Ellery, and not in a good way, like we were solving the mystery together. Instead, it felt like I was stuck following her around even though I wanted to be doing anything else. That said, I did feel like I needed to finish this book once I started it, so I guess that’s on me. Read more (with spoilers) here.

Vladimir by Julia May Jonas. This book reminded me of Miranda July’s All Fours in many ways, mostly that I enjoyed reading it overall but don’t know what to think of it now that it’s done. I initially thought the twist at the end that brought it all down was overkill, but I think it’s fairly realistic and can’t think of another way for things to have played out. But overall, I kind of have the feeling of, “Okay, I read that.” It didn’t change me, it’s not something I’ll re-read, but I’m not angry I read it and I like the author’s writing enough to read another book by her, which I think is a favorable review overall.

Perfect Little Children by Sophie Hannah. This story was not compelling enough for a novel for me. A novella, maaaaybe. I initially found the concept interesting but it dragged on way too long, the suspense seemed low stakes, and it took forever to get a resolution. And that resolution was not particularly thrilling or dangerous to me, so by the end, I felt like I’d read all that for nothing.

The Pint of No Return by Ellie Alexander. The first book was somewhat meh to me, but interesting enough to make me want more of the characters and town. The second book definitely pulled me in, and I’m invested in the series now. I especially like Alexander’s overarching series mystery of Sloan’s parents.

Beyond a Reasonable Stout by Ellie Alexander. I think this was my least favorite murder in the series so far, but I did like how it all came to a head without being the typical cozy mystery “risky” resolution. I also love how the brewery is developing.

Without a Brew by Ellie Alexander. This has been my favorite mystery yet in this series. I think it was really interesting how it all came together and it kept me guessing the whole time.

October Round-Up

The Secret, Book & Scone Society by Ellery Adams. I’d heard of this series but the cover seemed pretty bland to me so I never picked it up. However, I needed a new ebook to read and this was available, so I gave it a try. I’m so glad I did! I love the depth and diversity of the characters and how their friendship began to form. I liked the mystery as well, and though I don’t typically like books that end on a blatant cliffhanger, I’ll allow it this time because I’m definitely going to keep reading it.

The Stillwater Girls by Minka Kent. This was a Kindle Unlimited read that kept me turning pages and had an interesting premise, but overall, it felt too… happy and light for a thriller. Everything was going well until the “twist” - I guess it’s possible for a woman to have such a traumatic birth that she forgets about it, and forgets her baby was kidnapped? I was rolling my eyes reading it but if it happened to someone, I won’t invalidate them. It was just too convenient in this book though, and completely glossed over. You’d think that would open up even more trauma, but Nicollette totally rallied and it was only an issue for like… three pages? Also the two isolated teens that she took in totally adjusted and there was no struggle with integrating them into her house, etc. I just didn’t buy it once those storylines converged. I think there was potential to make it interesting and thrilling but this didn’t deliver.

The Whispered Word by Ellery Adams. I’m loving this series! Each mystery is so interesting and has great twists that I don’t think of but don’t seem hokey or manufactured.

Things We Never Say by Caitlin Weaver. This book was interesting and well-written. Each POV felt different to me, and I feel like I got to know the characters. The ending seemed pretty rushed though.

Graphic Rage by Aubrey Hirsch. I was so excited to read this book! It’s like doomscrolling but fact-based, and it’s a book instead of a screen! So while it did make me angry because of the subject matter of feminism and politics, I love the illustrations and how everything has a source.

Such a Good Family by Caitlin Weaver. After reading the author’s other book, I was expecting an interesting story and good writing. But a lot of these sentences seemed grammatically incorrect (in the ebook anyway, hopefully it was a transcription/formatting issue??) and the story was pretty bland. It was too similar to her other book so I kept getting the characters mixed up. As with the other book, the ending here was really rushed and glossed over.

Sandwich by Catherine Newman. This book made me laugh out loud in some places, so I appreciate that. But it felt like it meandered on way too long. I was sick of Rocky about ¾ of the way through. Everything was also a bit too cutesy, quippy, and easily resolved. Then the ending dropped one bomb that was just totally glossed over in a way I feel Rocky wouldn’t, so I finished the book feeling really unsettled and unsatisfied.

Also was NOT a fan of all the flashbacks because of how it seemed crucial to know when they came in Rocky’s life, but never quite added up for me since most happened during their week at the beach (with a few fall situations to flesh it out, I suppose). Some summers Jamie is 4 and Rocky is pregnant. But another summer Jamie is four and Willa is a baby. And then there’s a fall when Jamie is five and Willa is not yet two. I guess technically Willa being not quite two could mean she was also not yet a year? But later there’s yet another summer when Jamie was four and Willa was not quite one. I kept highlighting them, determined to put together the timeline, but it’s so convoluted. The thing is, just hinting at the time period would have been enough because Rocky later tells Willa when these things happened - and that’s crystal clear. But having random sections start with the specific timing totally pulled me out of the book and made me try to calculate it myself.

Here are some of the wordings:

• When Jamie was three and I was very pregnant with Willa

• “...Jamie when he was four. I was pregnant…”

• “...a memory of Jamie at four, Willa a baby in the sling…”

• The summer Jamie was four and Willa was not yet one

• The summer Jamie was five and Willa was not yet two

• The summer Jamie was six and Willa was not yet three

As I said, I guess some of them could be possible, depending on the birthdates, but it was just so specific that I felt like I NEEDED to pay attention to it, so I did, and it didn’t really add up, pulled me out of the story, and just seemed like too much. Call me nitpicky but it is what it is.

The Book of Candlelight by Ellery Adams. Absolutely love the new characters introduced here, but the mystery felt a bit disjointed. Still felt cozy, though, and made me eager to read the next to ensure some of the new additions stuck around.

Ink and Shadows by Ellery Adams. This has been my least favorite installment in the series. The mystery wasn’t compelling to me and I felt like the women speaking out against “witchcraft” and banned books went silent way too easily compared to how things would have escalated in real life.

The Vanishing Type by Ellery Adams. I liked this a bit more than the last installment in the series but it still wasn’t my favorite. I do love McCabe and Bobbie being more active characters though.

Paper Cuts by Ellery Adams. I was glad to see some of Nora’s past coming after her in this book. After sharing the secret, then Bobbie coming into play, I thought something more would have to happen. This was a really good one, it felt a bit more dramatic and realistic than cozy, in a good way though. A series staying on the same level would get boring, so I appreciate how this mixed things up.

The Little Lost Library by Ellery Adams. This mystery was fun and made me wish I could see the little books Nora found! I also really liked the “A Rose for Emily” vibes with a twist.

That's Not My Name by Megan Lally. For being a suspense novel with a ticking bomb, this book was really slow to me. I didn’t care about either of the characters and thought the final twist, while not completely expected, didn’t really have much of an impact on the overall story for me.

The Body in the Bookstore by Ellie Alexander. I loved this one! The cute town pulled me in and the mystery festival had me hooked. I love the idea of solving her best friend’s death as a thread tying the books in the series together - definitely makes me want to read more.

The Face on the Milk Carton by Caroline B. Cooney. I read this whole series as a kid and was obsessed. Re-reading it was… not the same experience. I think part of it was that the ebook was formatted strangely, but the story jumped around a lot and focused way too much on random ideas (Denim and Lace anyone?) while glossing over really major emotional moments. I can see how it would be compelling for a younger reader (since it worked for me!) but the writing isn’t up to par compared to how it was in my memory.

Secondhand Spirits by Juliet Blackwell. Read for the Cozy Mystery Book Club. It took me a bit to get into this book because the character seemed a little flat at first, but by the last third of the book, I was hooked! Definitely interested in reading more.

Boom Town by Nic Stone. I love that Stone is writing for adults, and this is so well done. A lot of YA authors try for adult books but it’s just YA with a 27-year-old protagonist who acts 17… (Looking at you Holly Jackson, sorry). But Stone’s characters feel adult and the story was really compelling. Unfortunately, I feel like it’s a lot of build-up (excellent suspense) just to totally gloss over the critical action and the emotional beat that should have ended the book. I think even 10 extra pages - 5 for the climax and 5 for the emotional ending - would have completely elevated this book.

The Book Club for Troublesome Women by Marie Bostwick. I wanted to read this one based on the title alone, and went in blind otherwise. I like some historical fiction, and this era is one of my sweet spots. The characters made me think of my grandmother so I could really get into the story (and get outraged by a lot of the constraints that are becoming all too real once more). Walk Two Moons by Sharon Creech. I read this book a lot as a kid and still have my (aging, brittle) copy. My kid is reading it for school and while I remember the end, I wanted to revisit it. It always made me cry and this time was no exception. It’s still oh-so-good.

Secondhand Spirits by Juliet Blackwell

Secondhand Spirits by Juliet Blackwell

I read this for the October Cozy Mystery Book Club - check out the discussion HERE! 

It took me a bit to get into this book because the main character seemed a little flat at first. I could hardly remember her name, and she seemed pretty rigid and bland initially before showing more personality about halfway through. I also felt like a lot of characters were introduced really quickly and it was hard to remember who they all were until I saw more scenes with them. They were introduced as names and developed into characters later, instead of seeming fully-formed from the start, so that put me off a bit. But I was determined to make it through, and I was glad I stuck with it. 

By the last third of the book, I was hooked! I liked the learning the history of La Llorona and seeing her as a "character" in a way. I also didn't see the twist coming, but I think the clues were there if I had picked up on them. I think paying more attention to the characters from the start and being able to keep them separate in my mind might have helped me figure out the villain... but maybe not! I thought that part of the story was really well done.

The romance seemed a bit forced to me. While the female characters were all introduced quickly, by name only, and then became more developed, the males were all presented more as characters/by their roles... but they were flat. It seemed like several guys were interested in Lily and she didn't really react to any of them initially, so I wasn't sure how the romance would go. Then, whoosh, it all seemed to happen at once. I wish the romance hadn't really developed until later in the series, but overall I'm curious enough to want to read the second book.

Boom Town by Nic Stone

Boom Town by Nic Stone

I love that Stone is writing for adults, and this is so well done. A lot of YA authors try for adult books but it’s just YA with a 27-year-old protagonist who acts 17… (Looking at you Holly Jackson, sorry). But Stone’s characters feel adult and the story was really compelling. Unfortunately, I feel like it’s a lot of build-up (excellent suspense) just to totally gloss over the critical action and the emotional beat that should have ended the book. I think even 10 extra pages - 5 for the climax and 5 for the emotional ending - would have completely elevated this book.

With that said... I do have a lot of thoughts, but there are spoilers, so click at your own risk: