Fun Home: a Family Tragicomic by Alison Bechdel
This is a graphic novel about a girl who finds out her
father is gay only after she comes out as a lesbian. He dies shortly after, and
she remembers her strange relationship with him, as well as her childhood
growing up in and around funeral homes. There could have been a lot more
emotion to the story, but I think telling it as a graphic novel kind of
diminished that possibility. The drawings didn’t add much depth or insight, but
it would have been a sparse story without them.
I've also read Are You My Mother? by Bechdel
and had a similar reaction regarding the emotion in the book. I can see how
both books were therapeutic for Bechdel to write and illustrate, but I
didn't get much of that from the drawings or even the story. They were both
interesting, but dragged a bit with the navel-gazing, heavy literary
references, and other stuff that could have been cut out to make a snappy,
impactful graphic novel.
Fun Home is going to be performed as a play at
Playhouse on the Square in May, so I'm excited to see how it translates to the
stage. If you've read much of this blog at all, you know I love comparing books
to movies and play versions of themselves, so we'll see how Fun Home turns
out!
Fun Home is one of my favorite books. I really like how Bechdel weaves the literary references into her story and her father's story and makes the book work on so many different levels. But I'm an English major so I'm inclined to appreciate intertexuality.
ReplyDeleteI'm an English major too, so I understood the references and appreciated them on some level, but I read graphic novels/memoirs because I love the deep connection you can feel between the images and words - sometimes it's emotional, sometimes it's just fun. This was pretty heavy for me, and I don't think making it a graphic memoir really added anything to it.
Delete